Friday, October 2, 2009

A People Pleaser

I'm brainwashed.

My parents have spoon fed me my convictions for as long as I can remember.

I'm sheltered and delusional. I'll say I'm happy, and I might seem well-adjusted, but it's only because I've been trained to answer your questions with a smile on my face.

Don't you believe it.

All right, so, depending on where you might be coming from, you're either laughing by now, or wondering where I'm going with this. Or both.

Some of the commenters on "What to Write" asked for blogging tips. Recent events have given me an idea for tip number one: how to deal with opposition.

I've shared before that many anonymous comments don't make it through moderation (though some do). They consist of variations of "You're so brainwashed. I feel sorry for you." Part of the reason I don't post them is because (well, for one thing, I don't have to -it's my blog, na-na-na-na-na... but, for another) I'm not sure how to respond to this sort of "sympathy."

I could defend myself: I'm not brainwashed. But then, are brainwashed people even aware that they're brainwashed -if so, do they even want to break free from their closed off little corner of the universe (think "1984" -doublethink, doublespeak -I'm Winston post-brainwashing and 2 + 2 = 5. And I'm good with that.)? I could try to prove it: I'm happy. I'm well-adjusted. Though it's not perfect, I love my life, and I love the journey I'm taking. But then, do delusional people know when they're unhappy? "Well, you think just like your parents do." Not always. I've had my moments of rebellion and doubt, as has everyone. But my parents and I are all believers working towards the same goal (to glorify God), so when we come to an impasse, they don't go for shock therapy; we pull out God's Word and work it out. All right, so I've told you I'm not sheltered. What say you to that? Well, obviously, I'm just not a critical thinker. If I was, I'd read all that material and come to the same conclusions as the sane half of the population. Duh.

I'm aware that this blog has two distinct audiences: those who are likeminded, and those who are not. I'm sure some people read out of sheer curiosity, something akin to examining exotic wildlife, or maybe even watching a car wreck when you can't seem to tear your eyes away. Another distinction I've become increasingly aware of is Christians and non-Christians.

For that audience of likeminded Christian girls, I'd like to offer some advice, if I may: you can't please everyone. You might share the gospel, about how Christ radically saved a wretched sinner like you, and all your listener hears is the cacophony of his own assumptions: obviously, you think you're better than they are. You may speak about how you are disenchanted with the American educational system, and all readers will see is judgment of that single mom who drops her kids off at school every day because of the terms of her divorce state that she must. You may write about a family vacation, and a sentence from your description will be analyzed to death. You may say you like the color orange, and people will feel slighted because you didn't mention the other colors of the rainbow.

All right, perhaps that last one was a bit of a stretch. But I've been accused of being everything from a hypocrite to a Holocaust denier since I started blogging; the written word is a powerful tool for communication, but sometimes, people will hear what they want to hear. This isn't just true of the blogosphere -it happens in abundance in real life as well. How do we deal with it when it does?

First off, be polite. Assume every question is a genuine inquiry, and answer it as graciously as you can, as hard as that might be.

Secondly, don't take personal offense. People might be unkind and reactionary for a host of reasons. Yes, sometimes, people are just ornery, but, often, it's because of hurt in their own lives, or a genuine misunderstanding or a blind spot. Sometimes, it has nothing to do with you. Pray for them, and try to be understanding, not annoyed.

Third, learn when explanation is superfluous. Some people are just looking for a fight. When graciousness fails, sometimes we need to realize that the Lord changes hearts. The last thing we need to do is to enforce a mistaken impression by getting an attitude or pouting.

Forth, speaking of pouting, take every remark as a chance to practice humility. We are decorated dust; we are fallible humankind. When we become offended, often, we can trace that offense back to pride in our lives. Learn to laugh at yourself. When others poke fun at you, two things can remove the sting: one, knowing you are merely a sinner saved by grace.; and, two, realizing that you are the cherished child of a sovereign King. You don't need earthly approval. Now, if someone offers biblical criticism, humility also comes into play as you seek to grow in Christ and accept reproof.

Fifth, learn when to walk away. Especially from the Internet. The fact of the matter is, in the real world, people tend to keep their opinions to themselves a lot more than the blogosphere's constant stream of consciousness. When you're bombarded with rude comments or you come across a hurtful link, turn off the computer before you do something you'll regret (battles of the wills usually end in an unsavory stalemate online) and spend time with your flesh-and-blood friends and family who love and know you well enough to realize you're not crazy. =)

As to that second group of readers, I'm slightly amused that I alternately interest/amuse/disgust/confuse you enough to hold your attention. I'm always willing to answer sincere inquiries to the best of my ability. But you might be disappointed when my reasoning comes down to a confident, "Because the Bible tells me so" (an over-simplification, to be sure). I hope the Lord can use what you read here for his glory.

All in all, I'm an apologist's daughter: I like to argue. =) But fruitless debate is a time-waster, an energy-drainer, and a joy-sapper. At the end of the day, I can't please everyone, not on the Internet, and not in real life. Because, you know what? I am weird. A peculiar person. A child of God who's held to a standard that's confusing to the world, who's loved by a love that none can fully comprehend... and, as the children of God, that love should manifest itself in how we deal with likeminded brethren, with brethren who disagree, and with non-believers who just don't get us. With graciousness, humility, and boldness, and armed with God's Word, we truly have nothing to fear.

25 thoughts shared:

Lauren said...

Amen and thank you! I've often admired your firm yet gracious responses to some very rude web-lurkers. Although I've not yet experienced this wonderful sort of popularity on my own blog, I know I will refer to your advice if ever I do!

Mikaela said...

Thanks for such a practical topic! I will promptly apply it not only to my blogging encounters, but also to my real-life encounters. I struggle the most with taking things personally; even innocent criticisms get me out of countenance. Thankfully, however, I have yet to encounter a rude person in my blogging, even after 2years!

One Bright Corner

Jenna said...

I love the last line:

"With Graciousness, humility, boldness and armed with God's Word, we truly have nothing to fear."

Amen! HE's our refuge and fortress; our deliverer!! Thank you for the encouragement to stand strong in Christ Jesus...you're right, we can't please everyone. And the only one that we should be trying to please is our Almighty God~

Your sister in the Lord,
~Jenna~

Lynne in NC said...

Another well spoken entry.

I enjoy reading your posts and about your life. You comments make me laugh, because you have a great sense of humor; cry, because your words are beautiful; and ponder the many thought provoking ideas you present.

I am thankful you take the time to write and share with all of us.

Peace.

Tammy said...

Truthful...Thoughtful...Wise...and Right on Target! Your advice is well-heeded and duly taken. :o)

sastroope said...

HA HA! "I'm sure some people read out of sheer curiosity, something akin to examining exotic wildlife"

Observe the homeschooler in her natural habitat. Hunkered under the care of her mother, she is unaware of the approaching danger of anonymous bloggers and their impending attack on her sheltered and brainwashed thoughts. (Spoken with a British accent of course)

Sorry Jasmine, I couldn't resist. Great post as always.

Rachel C said...

Jasmine,
I don't know if I ever have, but I'll take this moment to thank you so much for taking the time to make this blog. It's filled with such encouraging, challenging advice that my mom and I love to ponder. You are an extremely gifted young lady and I hope you continue to share your convictions and passions with us out in Cyber Space. I can honestly say that I learn more about how to be a godly young lady from reading your posts than from anywhere else. (Besides my wonderful mother :)
Props also for using my vocabulary word of the week, "cacophony" in your blog entry today! I don't think I've ever heard anyone use that word in a sentence, lol!
Keep on writing!
Love in Christ,
Rachel C

Leanna said...

Great thoughts! Although I don't have this problem in the blog world, I've encountered it many times in the real world.

sastroope, you're hilarous! :) Sometimes I wonder if that's really what people think of us. ;)

Kelsey Anne Hoppman said...

That is so true. Wonderful post Jasmine!
It's so easy to try and be a people pleaser. I need to strive to be myself and worry about what I look like to God.
Keep up the great (even controversial) posts.

God Bless,
Kelsey

Amanda Read said...

Very good points about avoiding saying something you might regret. It takes time to cool down after an insult and then pray and consider what is worth saying - and what is worth the time. What we write on the internet is not permanently deletable, as far as technology goes.

This reminds me of when a liberal tried to argue that I was stuck in a Matrix, unable to see the real world and so dependent upon a lifestyle system that I had lost all reason and would die to defend it (he even sent me a clip of the movie just to emphasize his point). I couldn't help but respond (as coolly and politely as possible, of course) that quite frankly, I know more about the world than I want to know, and I am not the one who grew up dependent upon a system that would require me to spend 12 years of my life and 8 hours of my day being taught in a government-run institution. If that's not a Matrix, I don't know what is...but I'm certainly not in it!

Haha...at least, not in the context he was referring to. I suppose the original root word might have more pure and substantial meaning, but I would have to research that more thoroughly.

We know there are things worth defending and worth fighting for, but that doesn't mean we're dependent upon a system. We're dependent upon our Savior and don't have to function on humanistic mechanics and desperation - which is what our "opponents" are dependent upon - constantly trying to find a system that will save everybody from life's troubles.

This also brings to mind lyrics from the ZOEGirl song "Dead Serious", which is about a Christian girl's reaction to being mocked at for her convictions (it's fun and encouraging - you can hear it on this: http://www.playlist.com/playlist/16358841867):

"That's right, that's me
I don't care what you think
People talk all day, I don't care what they say

You think I’m delirious, a typical reaction
Aren’t you curious about my satisfaction?
Maybe you’re envious, a little furious
You can laugh, but I’m dead serious."


~Amanda~

roxanne said...

WELL SAID!!!!! I really admire how you have dealt with these(ahem!)rude comments. People who judge others are always the ones who often have no idea what they are talking about. This is not a judgment(just in case someone tried to use this against me);))this is something I have observed in my own life. Jasmine, i think you are a wonderful example of what a true lady is suppose to be.

Frank said...

Treading every question as a genuine inquiry and answering them graciously.....wow, thanks for writing that Jasmine. That definitely brings things into perspective for me personally, because I find myself having to defend the faith so much that I have begun assuming any question as some form of mockery. But yet Matthew 10:16 teaches us to be gentle as doves.....thanks for the gentle rebuke, although I'm sure it was unintentional.

Mrs. Lindblom said...

Jasmine,
This is such a wise, helpful article.
As a side, I love how you refer to humanity as "decorated dust"!

Your sister in Christ,
Mrs. Lindblom

Julie said...

Dear Jasmine,

"Brainwashed," is an archaic term. A more accurate description for someone in your position is a phenomenon known as Stockholm Syndrome. It was originally observed in kidnap victims who, over time, became sympathetic to their captors, and a similar phenomenon has been observed in many women and children living in religiously fundamentalist patriarchal households and societies (Islamic and Christian sects alike). It’s a survival mechanism, not a personality or intellectual deficit.

Please know, no matter what, YOU ARE a survivor. Remain steadfast and strong knowing God—the true God—is working through people in this country and throughout the world to prevent women and children from being subjected to the religious perversions imposed upon you.

God Bless,
Julie

Jasmine said...

Thanks, everyone, for the kind words. I enjoy reading every comment, and am humbled by your encouragement.

Mrs. Stroope,

Hilarious! =D That was exactly what I was thinking when I wrote that sentence.

Amanda,

I almost mentioned "The Matrix," in this post. =P You make some excellent points, as ever. I always enjoy reading your comments.

~J~

Jasmine said...

Julie,

While I appreciate your kindness, I'm not sure, quite, how you'd like me to respond to your comment (or if you were expecting a response at all). If your sympathy is genuine, I really do appreciate that you seem to care for me, even though you haven't even met me. Perhaps some of the confusion could be alleviated if I better understood what you mean by people "in my position." What do you see as "my position," I wonder?

I must say that I'm no more a captive than I'm sure you are; I am free to leave my home at any time I wish, free, if I please, to seek a different mode of education, free, if I like, to live on my own and to make my own way in the world. There are not mental or physical shackles binding me -no guilt and no condemnation. In fact, my parents have given me all of the tools I need should I ever like to succeed on my own, from a good education to a driver's license (almost got that last one -still chugging through driving lessons as I type -my mom was 18 when she got hers, Dad 19, so I come from a line of late drivers =). I'm an adult who is as free to live the life I believe God as called me to lead as you are not to read this blog if it so saddens you (though you are, indeed, welcome to read and to comment here, when you feel you have something fruitful to add to any discussion).

As much kindness as you have shown, I must repeat that you don't know me, or what position I'm in. You speak from presuppositions that no amount of convincing on my part could set to rights, and you speak with a condescending tone that my own "patriarchal" father wouldn't even use with me. =) There is only one thing that keeps me on the road I'm traveling: the love of my Savior, and of his precepts. I am *his* captives, ransomed by redeeming blood, loyal to him and his will alone. I do realize that there are different interpretations of His Word, and know that I have been called to love and respect those who hold differing views than I do on the subjects therein.

And so, while I do want to remain respectful in this comment, I have to point out something that bothers me:

Jasmine said...

You you refer to me as a "survivor," and admit that you see my lifestyle as one that is "imposed" upon me. I have to wonder, have you any proof of that statement? Have I said anything to give you reason to believe that I've been trapped or victimized? If not, here's what it seems to me like you're saying (and please correct me if I'm wrong): As a woman, I'm free to live whatever lifestyle I deem fit... so long as it's not a "fundamentalist" lifestyle.

I need to do whatever makes me happy; as long as what gives me joy isn't residing under a patriarchal roof.

I'm an intellectual; as long as I don't have a "blind spot" about family dynamics.

So as long as I don't believe in male headship, I'm a free-thinking individual, but the moment I do, it's a symbol that I've been brainwashed (or, have Stockholm Syndrome).

But it's impossible for someone who does not have a shaky psychological condition (either that of a victimized woman or that of a domineering man) to come to the views I hold simply by a right reading of God's Word.

If this is what you're saying, It sounds like a lose-lose to me. Add in the fact that you've compared my upbringing to that of a kidnapped child, and the outlook seems very bleak indeed. Unless I conform to a different interpretation of the Scriptures, I'm seen as a... conformist?

As a child of God, it is not only your prerogative, but your duty to look into the Lord's Word and to make decisions that are pleasing to him. All I ask is that his Word -not modern psychobabble or rebellion that's as old as Genesis 3 -be your guide in those decisions. I won't try to twist your arm and make you believe as I do, nor will I endeavor to convince you that you've been hoodwinked or bamboozled, or that you're trapped in whatever lifestyle it is that you ascribe to. In turn, I ask -as kindly as I can- that you leave your assumptions (and, frankly, your patronizing tone) out of future discussions on my blog.

If you have any questions, I'm glad to answer them. If your only aim is to let me know how sorry you feel for me, I appreciate your compassion, and that you were bold enough to share what you believe the Lord laid on your heart to say to me. I hope, in turn, that you can appreciate what I believe that the Lord has laid on my hear to say in turn.

In closing (and please excuse the length of this comment), though, I must repeat your words with an admonition of my own: Remain steadfast and strong knowing God—the true God—is and has always been working through his church, by his power, and for his glory -from generation to generation, from everlasting to everlasting -to prevent men, women, and children from being subjected to the religious perversions imposed upon those who do not understand the beauty and the purpose of his precepts.

Respectfully,
Jasmine

Melissa M. said...

Amen! Thanks for your thoughts! :)

Handmaidens of Heaven said...

Dear Jasmine,

Thank you again for your great post!
I have to admit that I enjoy a good debate as well, whether I am taking an active part or simply listening to my father's dialogue with someone else. During one of the latter instances, Daddy's worthy opponent (who is also my uncle) turned and appealed to me on a subject. I responded fairly briefly, but in favor of my father's view, and my uncle came back with, "You're just brainwashed."
I did not wish to engage my uncle further at that time, but Daddy and I talked later and I thought, "Aren't we all brainwashed?" I mean, we all come to a discussion or debate with presuppositions that color our responses on every level. Even more, every aspect of our lives flow out of our unique and individual "brainwashes." (I love manufacturing new word variations.) =D Either way, brainwash is, at its core, world view.

We can choose to be "brainwashed" by God (being "transformed by the renewing of our minds") or by any other forms of brainwashing the world offers. There is no nuetrality on this ground. Passivity or unawareness in world-view is, in itself a choice. ("...so that they are without excuse," - from Romans 1:18-22)

An "accusation" of "brainwash" is then beside the question of any dissagreement. My father explained to me that a debate between two unique world views may often become as profitable as an argument between two people who speak different languages. Without the grace of God, all of us are liable to fall into a blind trap of wrong thinking from which no human wisdom can pull us. I loved your last line as well for this reason!

Blessings from a similarly brainwashed Christ follower!

Emily L.

Jasmine said...

Emily,

I always love reading your comments -you have such a way with words; you express your thoughts (which are often so closely aligned with my thoughts =) very well!

I especially loved this line: "A debate between two unique world views may often become as profitable as an argument between two people who speak different languages." How true that is!

And also quite true, that "without the grace of God, all of us are liable to fall into a blind trap of wrong thinking from which no human wisdom can pull us."

Hm... I'm very tempted to write a follow-up post on this article based simply on those insightful words alone. I believe I shall...

Gratefully,
Jasmine

Leah said...

Jasmine; such GREAT wise words and well written responses to your commenters; when my daughter is old enough I'll encourage her to read through your encouraging articles on here! Be VERY blessed!

LissaBugPink said...

Thanx Jasmine!

Reading you blog makes me want to blog more!!!

Keep doing what your doing!

In Chirst,
Alissa Gill

Kate said...

There I was 16 and working in a women's clothing store. One of the managers just loved targeting me. She would ask personal questions and share personal stories and information that ruined my innocence. She hated that I was so "sheltered" and "didn't live life." I asked her what "living life meant." When she didn't answer I said, "does it mean getting drunk and sleeping around?" She said, "well, yes! C'mon! Come partying with me. I'll set you up with a one night stand. It's really fun!"

If that's life, then I don't want it. If that's not being sheltered, then build a fortress around me.

To live is Christ.

Miss Jocelyn said...

Thank you for this wonderful post, and thank you for be apart of the Feelin' Feminine blogroll. This article has been selected for our Bosom Friends column this month! You can find it here http://feelinfeminine.com/?p=2362

Pearls and Diamonds said...

I actually thought Julie was making a very witty and sarcastic joke. I have a hard time imagining anyone saying anything in seriousness that sounds so...brainwashed...excuse me, Stockholm Syndrome.

You know, I wouldn't really consider myself sheltered. I grew up protected, but now I work as a Crisis counselor at a Crisis Pregnancy Clinic--and I sit across from women who tell me horror stories of the liberation of women. Liberated from what? We've sprung the cell door to find what? The lion's mouth awaits. Boundaries are not chains--but privacy fences. We draw protective lines around ourselves, not to bind us to some horrible fate, but to preserve us from some horrible fate. The more I see these young "liberated women" weeping, confused, hurt, depressed, turning to a million different pain killers in an effort to block out the reality of their "liberation", the more I know that brainwashing has certainly occurred. A brainwashing that encourages women to despise the fact that they were made in God's image, and made to be temples of God, to have fellowship with God and to worship and obey God--for their joy. And that is supposed to be a low view of women? Christ liberated women from the curse--which was separation from God. If a feminist is one who looks out for the best interests of women--then I am a feminist.

And all those who call themselves feminists? They are slave traders, trading in human flesh. Trading eternity for an illusion of "having it their own way."

So, "women's liberation" means a rejection of all that we do best, all that gives us our unique place in human society, a throwing out of protection and wisdom and dependence because it makes us feel like the weaker vessel. In return, we remain the weaker vessel, but are left shattered by those we have rejected as protectors. We despise the very calling for which we were created an uniquely endowed, and think we will find more fulfillment in pursuing a path of our own choosing.

Poor, deluded, brainwashed women.

Poor women who are too bound and afraid to break the bonds and step into their full potential and be what God created them to be--worshipers.

Liberated by the Truth,
Abigail @ Pearls and Diamonds